THE JACKDAW DETECTIVE AGENCY
TOP SECRET — CASE FILE 0001
THE BLACKTHORN FILE
CASE SOLVED — CONFIDENTIAL
THE MURDERER: CLARA VALE
Clara Vale, Evelyn Harcourt's private secretary, murdered her employer in the study of Blackthorn House.
Evelyn had discovered discrepancies in the household accounts and intended to confront Clara over a missing ledger containing evidence of altered financial records.
Fearing exposure, Clara arranged to meet Evelyn at 9:30pm. During their confrontation, she struck Evelyn with the brass jackdaw ornament, killing her.
She removed the incriminating ledger and used the gramophone to create the impression that Evelyn was still alive after their meeting.
But Clara made several critical mistakes.
THE FOUR CLUES EXPLAINED
01 — THE APPOINTMENT DIARY
Evelyn's diary contained the entry "9:30PM — C. VALE", with the word "LEDGER" written beneath it.
Evelyn had arranged to confront Clara about the financial discrepancies.
02 — THE TRAM TICKET
Clara claimed her 9:18pm tram ticket proved she was travelling away from Blackthorn House.
However, the ticket clearly read:
TOWN → BLACKTHORN
Clara was travelling towards the house, not away from it. Her alibi was false.
03 — THE MISSING LEDGER
The missing ledger contained evidence of altered cash accounts, for which Clara was responsible.
Its disappearance gave Clara both a motive for murder and a reason to remove evidence from the study.
04 — THE GRAMOPHONE
Music was heard playing at approximately 9:40pm.
The record lasted just 3 minutes and 42 seconds, and the gramophone had no automatic timer.
Someone had to start it manually. The music was therefore no proof that Evelyn was alive when it was heard.
Clara used the gramophone to confuse the timeline of the murder.
THE FINAL CONCLUSION
Clara Vale returned to Blackthorn House, confronted Evelyn Harcourt, murdered her with the brass jackdaw, removed the ledger and attempted to construct a false timeline.
The tram ticket exposed her lie. The ledger revealed her motive. The gramophone explained her deception.
CASE 0001 — CLOSED